Not Hearing Back After an Interview? Don’t Panic!

Premierehire Executive search and leadership strategies

The job or internship search can be an incredibly tough experience and take a toll on “mental health.” There are a few common things that job seekers panic about that aren’t really “bad signs” at all.

One big panic-inducing event is not hearing back for a few days (or sometimes weeks) after an interview. This is the most common situation where people really get into their own heads and cause themselves a lot of (unnecessary) stress.

Think of it this way, you get a similar effect when you start dating someone. It sounds ridiculous but… You go on a great date, you feel awesome about it, you leave, and you wait for a call.

Immediately after the date you’re feeling awesome. Day 2 you’re feeling a little anxious (why aren’t they texting me??). On day 3 you’re feeling even more like the relationship is doomed before it’s even started and by day 4, you’ve probably given up all hope.

Meanwhile, the person on the other end just had a super-busy week at work and ends up reaching out a few days later without thinking there is anything wrong.  Yet you’ve spent all this time and energy freaking out and losing confidence.  Does this sound familiar to anyone?

This is the same thing with candidates and recruiters!

You leave an interview feeling really good and then as the days pass by you lose more and more confidence and start to assume the worst.  However, there are literally tons of reasons why you may not hear back right away so please don’t panic over this.

Whether the recruiter is finishing up a week of interviews with other candidates, talking to the hiring manager to get feedback, or even reviewing the scope of the job, it generally doesn’t have anything to do with you.  And it definitely is not an indication that you’ve done a bad job.

If you were a definite “no” you’d actually be likely to hear that sooner.  When you are in consideration for a job, things can tend to drag a bit as the company determines next steps.

Here is an exercise to help you combat this panic:

Write down how you feel right when you leave an interview:
Are you feeling really good about your answers and interactions?  Did you feel like you really connected with your interviewer?  This will help make sure “time” doesn’t “change your mind” about how you did that day.

Take notes on what the interviewer says about next steps:
This doesn’t always happen but good interviewers are clear about timelines and next steps (you can also always feel free to ask this in the interview).  Write down this information so you can remember what expectation was set in terms of hearing more details on what’s next.

When you’re having a panic moment because you’re not hearing back, look at this list:
Like we talked about before, there are lots of different reasons why the recruiter or company doesn’t get back to you really quickly after your interview.  The brain will automatically blame you for that (and put the idea into your head that they’re not calling you because you did a bad job).  Don’t let it!  Look at the list, remind yourself how you felt walking out of the interview, and wait to hear more.

Even if you didn’t make these types of notes right after your interview, that doesn’t mean you can’t think clearly back to that day and be really honest with yourself about how it went.  Try to figure out the source of your panic.  Is it because you really think you did a terrible job or is it just anxiety that has come from some time passing. After 1-2 weeks, you may want to reach out to request an update.


The Author

Leanne Abraham helps leaders and teams reach higher levels of performance. She supports leadership teams as an executive team coach, facilitator, trainer, and advisor.

She and her team also help organizations find and retain the right people through her 4 Phase Executive Search and New Leader Integration Solutions.

Leanne is a certified executive coach and team coach (EMCC); is a certified coach for Birkman Leadership and Career Assessments, has completed training with the Adizes Institute, Tony Robbins coaching, the European Mentoring & Coaching Council (EMCC), and the Global Team Coaching Institute (GTCI).

Leanne serves clients throughout the US and Canada, ranging in size and industry.

On a personal note, Leanne is an avid reader, aspiring author, student of servant leadership, mother of 2, and loves hockey and skiing. She is expanding her career coaching program to provide support to executives wanting to move up or transition and she recently completed her team coaching practicum under David Clutterbuck and GTCI.

If you are looking to elevate your team, your leadership, or your career, please contact Leanne at or book a no charge consult.

Subscribe to our Blog

Receive the latest blogs on how to build a great team, grow leaders, and excel as a leader

You have successfully subscribed and we have sent you a confirmation email!

Looking to make a change? Get search tips from our experts in our free Job Search e-Guide.